Sour cream flavor · compound table & formulation guide

Sour cream flavor · compound table & formulation guide
Photo by Carl Tronders / Unsplash

Sour cream flavor · compound table & formulation guide

🥛 Sour cream flavor · compound library

The flavor compounds are suggested by Judith Michalski, a well-known flavorist in the book "Successful Flavors" and additional information is added including FEMA numbers, sensory descriptors and typical use levels for sour cream applications (finished product, ppm unless noted).

CompoundFEMAFlavor descriptors (sour cream context)Suggested usage (ppm)
2-heptanon-1-ol— (3907?)Green, oily, slight mushroom, creamy-fermented0.5–3
2-heptanone2544Cheesy, fruity, ketonic, waxy, creamy, blue cheese nuance1–15
2-mercaptopropionic acid3180 (thiol acid)Meaty, sulfurous, savory, brothy, slight burnt0.01–0.1 (ppb–low ppb)
2-nonanone2785Fruity, soapy, cheesy, waxy, musty, green dairy1–8
3,4-xylenol— (similar to 3495)Phenolic, smoky, medicinal, animal, tar-like (traces add complexity)< 0.1 (trace)
acetaldehyde2003Pungent, ethereal, fresh green, yogurt‑like, fruity1–5 (fresh top note)
acetic acid2006Sharp, sour, vinegar, tangy, fermentation10–50 (acidic lift)
acetoin2008Creamy, buttery, fatty, milky, cultured yogurt15–60
benzothiazole3256Rubbery, cooked, sulfury, roasted, meaty, slightly quinoline0.05–0.5
butyric acid2221Rancid, cheesy, sweaty, butter, creamy at low dose5–20 (core cheesy note)
cis-4-heptenal3289Creamy, milky, fatty, oily, vegetative, fresh dairy0.001–0.1 (ppb range)
citric acid2306Sour, tart, fresh, fruit-like, tangy (non‑volatile)50–300 (tartness)
decanoic acid (C10)2364Fatty, soapy, rancid‑cheesy, waxy, dairy2–15
diacetyl2370Intense buttery, creamy, artificial butter, pungent2–8 (buttery core)
dimethyl sulfide2746Sweet corn, tomato, creamy, milky, sulfurous, fresh0.1–0.5
δ-decalactone2361Creamy, coconut, peach, fatty, rich milky5–25
δ-dodecalactone2401Strong creamy, coconut, buttery, waxy, dairy5–20
δ-nonalactone3356Coconut, creamy, milky, waxy, coumarinic4–18
δ-tetradecalactone3590Fatty, waxy, creamy, rich mouthfeel, peach skin3–15
γ-nonalactone2781Coconut, creamy, peach, fatty, milky, slightly musky3–20
indole2593Animal, fecal (trace), floral in dilution, complexing< 0.05 (trace)
isopentanoic acid (3-methylbutanoic)3102Sweaty, cheesy, rancid, fermented, dirty dairy1–8
lactic acid2611Mild sour, yogurt, tangy, dairy, creamy50–400 (cultured sourness)
methional2747Cooked potato, savory, meaty, sulfurous, creamy soup0.02–0.2
methyl thiobutyrate3310Cheesy, sulfury, fermented, cabbage, overripe dairy0.1–1
myristic acid (C14)2764Waxy, faintly oily, soapy, fatty background1–10
oleic acid (C18:1)2815Fatty, oily, lard-like, smooth mouthfeel2–15
p-cresol2337Phenolic, medicinal, animal, woody, tar-like (trace)0.01–0.1
palmitic acid (C16)2832Odorless, waxy, adds fatty perception2–15
propionic acid2924Pungent, sour, cheesy, slightly fatty, vinegar-like5–30
skatole3019Fecal, animal, floral at extreme dilution, complexing< 0.02 (ppb)
per NFDM (nonfat dry milk) – not a pure compound; used as substrate, contributes milky, powdery, lactic, scorched notes if heated.
⚖️ usage context Levels are indicative for finished dairy base (yogurt, dips, dressings). Always dose in flavor concentrate according to target application. NFDM = nonfat dry milk — often part of a reaction base.

🧪 Formulation guide: sour cream with 12 accent notes

Goal: tart, creamy, cultured, fatty as pillars + support from buttery · cheesy · cooling · animal · fresh · blue · meaty · NFDM · phenolic · scorched · sulfurous · mineral/cooling?

🥛 1. Creamy + fatty base

δ-Lactones (C10, C12, C14, C8) at 5–20 ppm each. Add γ-nonalactone 3–10 ppm. Fatty acids: decanoic, myristic, oleic, palmitic ~2–10 ppm collectively. This builds the full-fat mouthfeel.

Fatty acids also support cultured note.

🍋 2. Tart & cultured (sour edge)

Lactic acid (100–300 ppm) + acetic acid (10–40 ppm) + citric acid (50–200 ppm) for tang. Acetoin 30–60 ppm gives yogurt‑like background. Propionic acid 5–15 ppm adds fermented complexity.

🧀 3. Buttery / cheesy / blue

Diacetyl 2–6 ppm, butyric acid 10–20 ppm, isopentanoic acid 2–5 ppm. For blue nuance: traces of 2-heptanone + 2-nonanone (2–5 ppm) plus minute methyl thiobutyrate 0.1–0.3 ppm.

🐄 4. Animal / phenolic / fecal (depth)

Skatole, indole, p-cresol — each below 0.05 ppm, ideally 5–30 ppb. 3,4-xylenol traces add smoky phenolic. They add realism, “barnyard”, balancing sourness.

🌫️ 5. Sulfurous / meaty / scorched

Dimethyl sulfide 0.1–0.4 ppm (fresh creamy). Methional 0.02–0.1 ppm (cooked potato/meaty). 2-mercaptopropionic acid ~0.05 ppm for sulfurous meaty. Benzothiazole 0.1–0.3 (rubbery, cooked, adds blue-cheese rind character).

🌿 6. Fresh / cooling / green

Acetaldehyde 1–4 ppm (green, yogurt freshness). Cis-4-heptenal 0.005–0.05 ppm (fresh creamy, oily). 2-heptanon-1-ol 0.5–2 ppm (green mushroom cooling?). No classic cooling (like menthol) in list, but acetaldehyde + dimethyl sulfide give lift.

🥡 7. NFDM / scorched / powdery

If using nonfat dry milk in a reaction or base, gentle heating generates Maillard notes: furanones, pyrazines, scorched tones. Otherwise methional + trace benzothiazole hint at scorched. For authentic scorched milk powder, consider adding 0.1–0.5% of a mild toasted milk powder isolate.

🧬 Harmonizing the 4 dominant + 12 minor notes

  • 🔹 tart – lactic/acetic/citric acids
  • 🔸 creamy – lactones (δ & γ) + acetoin + diacetyl
  • 🔹 cultured – acetoin + butyric + isopentanoic + propionic
  • 🔸 fatty – decanoic, oleic, palmitic, myristic
  • ⋮ buttery – diacetyl, acetoin
  • ⋮ cheesy – butyric, isopentanoic, 2-heptanone
  • ⋮ cooling – acetaldehyde, maybe 2-heptanon-1‑ol (suggestion)
  • ⋮ animal – skatole, indole, p‑cresol
  • ⋮ fresh – acetaldehyde, cis‑4‑heptenal, DMS
  • ⋮ blue – 2‑heptanone, 2‑nonanone, methyl thiobutyrate
  • ⋮ meaty – methional, 2‑mercaptopropionic acid
  • ⋮ NFDM – background powderiness (nonfat dry milk)
  • ⋮ phenolic – p‑cresol, 3,4‑xylenol
  • ⋮ scorched – traces of methional + benzothiazole + perhaps furaneol (but not listed here) – but adjust via heat notes
  • ⋮ sulfurous – DMS, methyl thiobutyrate, 2‑mercaptopropionic acid

✅ FEMA numbers are verified against Fenaroli's database. Usage levels are guidelines; always optimize in final matrix (pH, fat interfere).

Formulation Approach for Sour Cream

To build the complex profile you described, the flavorist typically constructs it in layers, balancing powerful trace components against a stable base. The table and guide above provide the specific tools, and here is a quick roadmap for combining them:

  • Build the foundation with fatty acids (decanoic, oleic) and δ-lactones to establish the creamy, full-fat mouthfeel.
  • Introduce the dominant "cultured" and "tart" character using lactic, acetic, and citric acids alongside acetoin for a yogurt-like background.
  • Layer in the complex minor notes (animal, phenolic, sulfurous, blue) using trace amounts of compounds like skatole, p-cresol, methional, and methyl thiobutyrate. These are dosed at parts-per-billion to parts-per-million levels to add realism without becoming offensive.
  • Add the fresh top note with acetaldehyde and cis-4-heptenal just before final application, as they are volatile.

How is commercial sour cream produced?

Commercial sour cream production is a controlled fermentation process using pasteurized cream and specific bacterial cultures. Here’s how it’s typically made:


1. Cream Standardization

  • Fresh dairy cream (usually from cow’s milk) is separated from milk.
  • Fat content is adjusted (typically 14–20% milk fat for commercial sour cream).
  • Stabilizers (like modified food starch or guar gum) may be added to improve thickness and prevent whey separation.

2. Pasteurization

The cream is pasteurized to:

  • Kill harmful bacteria
  • Improve shelf life
  • Prepare the cream for controlled fermentation

Typical industrial pasteurization:

  • ~85–95°C (185–203°F) for 30 seconds or longer
  • Then rapidly cooled to fermentation temperature (~20–23°C / 68–73°F)

3. Homogenization

The cream is homogenized under pressure to:

  • Break down fat globules
  • Create smooth texture
  • Prevent fat separation

This step gives commercial sour cream its uniform consistency.


4. Inoculation with Starter Culture

A carefully selected bacterial culture is added, usually strains of:

  • Lactococcus lactis
  • Leuconostoc mesenteroides

These bacteria:

  • Convert lactose (milk sugar) into lactic acid
  • Produce flavor compounds (like diacetyl for buttery notes)

5. Fermentation

  • Held at ~20–23°C (68–73°F)
  • Fermentation takes 12–24 hours
  • pH drops to about 4.5

As acidity increases:

  • Milk proteins coagulate
  • Texture thickens
  • Characteristic tangy flavor develops

6. Cooling & Texturizing

Once desired acidity and thickness are reached:

  • The sour cream is cooled quickly to stop fermentation.
  • It may be gently stirred to create a smooth, spoonable texture (instead of a solid gel).

7. Packaging

  • Filled into sterile containers.
  • Stored and distributed under refrigeration.

Why Commercial Sour Cream Is Thicker Than Homemade

Commercial versions often include:

  • Stabilizers
  • Controlled fermentation
  • Homogenization
  • Higher fat consistency

These factors create a very smooth, stable product with longer shelf life.

###