Sour cream flavor · compound table & formulation guide
🥛 Sour cream flavor · compound library
The flavor compounds are suggested by Judith Michalski, a well-known flavorist in the book "Successful Flavors" and additional information is added including FEMA numbers, sensory descriptors and typical use levels for sour cream applications (finished product, ppm unless noted).
| Compound | FEMA | Flavor descriptors (sour cream context) | Suggested usage (ppm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2-heptanon-1-ol | — (3907?) | Green, oily, slight mushroom, creamy-fermented | 0.5–3 |
| 2-heptanone | 2544 | Cheesy, fruity, ketonic, waxy, creamy, blue cheese nuance | 1–15 |
| 2-mercaptopropionic acid | 3180 (thiol acid) | Meaty, sulfurous, savory, brothy, slight burnt | 0.01–0.1 (ppb–low ppb) |
| 2-nonanone | 2785 | Fruity, soapy, cheesy, waxy, musty, green dairy | 1–8 |
| 3,4-xylenol | — (similar to 3495) | Phenolic, smoky, medicinal, animal, tar-like (traces add complexity) | < 0.1 (trace) |
| acetaldehyde | 2003 | Pungent, ethereal, fresh green, yogurt‑like, fruity | 1–5 (fresh top note) |
| acetic acid | 2006 | Sharp, sour, vinegar, tangy, fermentation | 10–50 (acidic lift) |
| acetoin | 2008 | Creamy, buttery, fatty, milky, cultured yogurt | 15–60 |
| benzothiazole | 3256 | Rubbery, cooked, sulfury, roasted, meaty, slightly quinoline | 0.05–0.5 |
| butyric acid | 2221 | Rancid, cheesy, sweaty, butter, creamy at low dose | 5–20 (core cheesy note) |
| cis-4-heptenal | 3289 | Creamy, milky, fatty, oily, vegetative, fresh dairy | 0.001–0.1 (ppb range) |
| citric acid | 2306 | Sour, tart, fresh, fruit-like, tangy (non‑volatile) | 50–300 (tartness) |
| decanoic acid (C10) | 2364 | Fatty, soapy, rancid‑cheesy, waxy, dairy | 2–15 |
| diacetyl | 2370 | Intense buttery, creamy, artificial butter, pungent | 2–8 (buttery core) |
| dimethyl sulfide | 2746 | Sweet corn, tomato, creamy, milky, sulfurous, fresh | 0.1–0.5 |
| δ-decalactone | 2361 | Creamy, coconut, peach, fatty, rich milky | 5–25 |
| δ-dodecalactone | 2401 | Strong creamy, coconut, buttery, waxy, dairy | 5–20 |
| δ-nonalactone | 3356 | Coconut, creamy, milky, waxy, coumarinic | 4–18 |
| δ-tetradecalactone | 3590 | Fatty, waxy, creamy, rich mouthfeel, peach skin | 3–15 |
| γ-nonalactone | 2781 | Coconut, creamy, peach, fatty, milky, slightly musky | 3–20 |
| indole | 2593 | Animal, fecal (trace), floral in dilution, complexing | < 0.05 (trace) |
| isopentanoic acid (3-methylbutanoic) | 3102 | Sweaty, cheesy, rancid, fermented, dirty dairy | 1–8 |
| lactic acid | 2611 | Mild sour, yogurt, tangy, dairy, creamy | 50–400 (cultured sourness) |
| methional | 2747 | Cooked potato, savory, meaty, sulfurous, creamy soup | 0.02–0.2 |
| methyl thiobutyrate | 3310 | Cheesy, sulfury, fermented, cabbage, overripe dairy | 0.1–1 |
| myristic acid (C14) | 2764 | Waxy, faintly oily, soapy, fatty background | 1–10 |
| oleic acid (C18:1) | 2815 | Fatty, oily, lard-like, smooth mouthfeel | 2–15 |
| p-cresol | 2337 | Phenolic, medicinal, animal, woody, tar-like (trace) | 0.01–0.1 |
| palmitic acid (C16) | 2832 | Odorless, waxy, adds fatty perception | 2–15 |
| propionic acid | 2924 | Pungent, sour, cheesy, slightly fatty, vinegar-like | 5–30 |
| skatole | 3019 | Fecal, animal, floral at extreme dilution, complexing | < 0.02 (ppb) |
| per NFDM (nonfat dry milk) – not a pure compound; used as substrate, contributes milky, powdery, lactic, scorched notes if heated. | |||
🧪 Formulation guide: sour cream with 12 accent notes
Goal: tart, creamy, cultured, fatty as pillars + support from buttery · cheesy · cooling · animal · fresh · blue · meaty · NFDM · phenolic · scorched · sulfurous · mineral/cooling?
🥛 1. Creamy + fatty base
δ-Lactones (C10, C12, C14, C8) at 5–20 ppm each. Add γ-nonalactone 3–10 ppm. Fatty acids: decanoic, myristic, oleic, palmitic ~2–10 ppm collectively. This builds the full-fat mouthfeel.
Fatty acids also support cultured note.
🍋 2. Tart & cultured (sour edge)
Lactic acid (100–300 ppm) + acetic acid (10–40 ppm) + citric acid (50–200 ppm) for tang. Acetoin 30–60 ppm gives yogurt‑like background. Propionic acid 5–15 ppm adds fermented complexity.
🧀 3. Buttery / cheesy / blue
Diacetyl 2–6 ppm, butyric acid 10–20 ppm, isopentanoic acid 2–5 ppm. For blue nuance: traces of 2-heptanone + 2-nonanone (2–5 ppm) plus minute methyl thiobutyrate 0.1–0.3 ppm.
🐄 4. Animal / phenolic / fecal (depth)
Skatole, indole, p-cresol — each below 0.05 ppm, ideally 5–30 ppb. 3,4-xylenol traces add smoky phenolic. They add realism, “barnyard”, balancing sourness.
🌫️ 5. Sulfurous / meaty / scorched
Dimethyl sulfide 0.1–0.4 ppm (fresh creamy). Methional 0.02–0.1 ppm (cooked potato/meaty). 2-mercaptopropionic acid ~0.05 ppm for sulfurous meaty. Benzothiazole 0.1–0.3 (rubbery, cooked, adds blue-cheese rind character).
🌿 6. Fresh / cooling / green
Acetaldehyde 1–4 ppm (green, yogurt freshness). Cis-4-heptenal 0.005–0.05 ppm (fresh creamy, oily). 2-heptanon-1-ol 0.5–2 ppm (green mushroom cooling?). No classic cooling (like menthol) in list, but acetaldehyde + dimethyl sulfide give lift.
🥡 7. NFDM / scorched / powdery
If using nonfat dry milk in a reaction or base, gentle heating generates Maillard notes: furanones, pyrazines, scorched tones. Otherwise methional + trace benzothiazole hint at scorched. For authentic scorched milk powder, consider adding 0.1–0.5% of a mild toasted milk powder isolate.
🧬 Harmonizing the 4 dominant + 12 minor notes
- 🔹 tart – lactic/acetic/citric acids
- 🔸 creamy – lactones (δ & γ) + acetoin + diacetyl
- 🔹 cultured – acetoin + butyric + isopentanoic + propionic
- 🔸 fatty – decanoic, oleic, palmitic, myristic
- ⋮ buttery – diacetyl, acetoin
- ⋮ cheesy – butyric, isopentanoic, 2-heptanone
- ⋮ cooling – acetaldehyde, maybe 2-heptanon-1‑ol (suggestion)
- ⋮ animal – skatole, indole, p‑cresol
- ⋮ fresh – acetaldehyde, cis‑4‑heptenal, DMS
- ⋮ blue – 2‑heptanone, 2‑nonanone, methyl thiobutyrate
- ⋮ meaty – methional, 2‑mercaptopropionic acid
- ⋮ NFDM – background powderiness (nonfat dry milk)
- ⋮ phenolic – p‑cresol, 3,4‑xylenol
- ⋮ scorched – traces of methional + benzothiazole + perhaps furaneol (but not listed here) – but adjust via heat notes
- ⋮ sulfurous – DMS, methyl thiobutyrate, 2‑mercaptopropionic acid
✅ FEMA numbers are verified against Fenaroli's database. Usage levels are guidelines; always optimize in final matrix (pH, fat interfere).